Print Print |

Ducey’s Results-Based Funding Favors High-Income Schools

Who Are the Winners and What Results Can We Expect? 

PDF Version 

The largest of Governor Ducey’s twelve education initiatives is a proposed $38 million for a bonus for excelling schools. He says this is part of his promise to expand access to high quality education for all students – no matter where they live and no matter where they can afford to live.

The Governor has presented this proposal to appear that it will offer more resources to lower income students to help close the achievement gap.

But a look at the figures reveals a much different picture.

  • Two thirds of the funding — 65% goes to high income schools.
  • 77% of the students reached go to high income schools.
  • This bonus funding reaches 23%– nearly one in four — of all students in charter schools and only 11% of district students.
  • There is nothing in the proposal that expands access to high quality schools, nothing that requires any expansion of the schools getting the bonus.
  • The proposal leaves less funding available to strengthen education in all the other schools with AZMerit scores below the top 10%.

The proposal gives a bonus of $400 per student to 61 district schools and 17 charter schools that serve lower income students. This bonus is based on the schools having the AZ Merit test scores in the top 10% of schools that have more than 60% of their students who qualify for the federal free and reduced price lunch program.

The proposal also gives a bonus of $225 per student to 112 district schools and 74 charter schools that serve higher income students. This bonus is based on the schools having AZ Merit test scores in the top 10% of all schools and having less than 60% of their students who qualify for the federal free and reduced price lunch program.



How Are Kids Doing in Your Legislative District?

Children’s Action Alliance is pleased to share with you our 2017 legislative district fact sheets, information about Arizona’s 30 legislative districts that is updated annually.

Our work is data-driven, and these fact sheets – which we share each year with lawmakers – give you a good sense of what we analyze on a regular basis to determine our policy priorities for the legislative session. We examine conditions for kids and working families in Arizona and focus our efforts on policies that will enhance the lives of children and their families.

Because conditions for children can vary widely from one region of the state to another, we have included the legislative district with the highest and lowest values, as well as the percentages for the state and nation as a whole for each data point.

We invite you to share this information with others. The more informed our policy makers and advocates are, the more likely we will be able to create a better quality of life for Arizona in general.

Policy Brief: Arizona Families and Economy Count on the Affordable Care Act

Our latest policy brief: Arizona Families and Economy Count on Health Coverage in the Affordable Care Act. ACA Fact book

What is “TANF”?

canstockphoto2914384Temporary Assistance to Needy Families, known as TANF, is a vital safety net program for families who need a little help between jobs. In fact, data shows parents who receive TANF only need it for a limited time, and stop getting benefits because they have found a job, not because they run out. Here’s a snapshot of TANF in Arizona.


New KIDS COUNT Data Ranks Arizona 45th in Nation

2016 KidsCount photoThe Annie E. Casey Foundation is out with its annual KIDS COUNT® Data Book, ranking Arizona 45th overall, up from 46th in 2015. The analysis ranks states on 16 data markers, including education, health, poverty and family situation, as well as community factors.

While Arizona is still in the bottom ten states, improvements in math proficiency were the most notable area of progress, propelling the state from 35th in 2015 to 18th in 2016. Arizona eighth graders performed better than the national average on the National Assessment of Educational Progress test, with 65% in our state not meeting proficiency, while nationally, that statistic is 68%.  Better scores can be attributed to an aggressive effort by public K-12 schools to adopt and meet more rigorous math standards.

Children growing up in Arizona continue to face big challenges, according to the report, with the state ranking in the bottom 10 for fourth grade reading, high school graduation and preschool participation. Additionally, one in four kids lives in a high poverty area, a factor that can have a dramatic impact on educational and future success.

The full KIDS COUNT® Data Book is available online. 

Arizona Welfare to Work Policies Doing Little to Help Families


In 1979, one out of every two families with children living in poverty in Arizona participated in welfare assistance. In 2014, almost two decades after welfare reform, only one out of eleven families with children living in poverty in Arizona participated in the new program. Those who are able to participate receive a monthly average of only $93 per person in Arizona — one of the lowest rates of assistance in the country. Seven out of ten participants are children.

Welfare reform was supposed to help people move into employment, but as we’ve found in our research, Arizona needs to work harder on “welfare to work.” Currently, Arizona diverts most Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) federal block grant funding away from work supports: only 2.7% of TANF funds spent in Arizona went to work related activities and supports.

Click here to download a copy of the data brief and learn just how little our policies do to help families go from “welfare to work.”

Essential DCS Charts and Graphs

The Department of Child Services (DCS) provides dozens of data indicators related to the reports of abuse or neglect it receives and the children and families who receive some kind of service from DCS.

Here at Children’s Action Alliance, we frequently go over the data available to us and the general public and try to make sense of it all and what it means to the children and families of Arizona.

The links below contains many of the charts and graphs we find are the most useful when determining how well Arizona’s children are protected from abuse and neglect.

DCS Charts and Graphs, Updated as of 12/31/15

DCS Data Dashboard_u_9_4_15

September is Grandfamilies/Kinship Care Month

Sixteen cities across Arizona have proclaimed September as Kinship Care Month, a time to recognize grandparents and other family members raising children who cannot be cared for by their own parents. Thank you to the following mayors for their support at September 1st news conferences in Pima and Maricopa Counties: Jackie Meck of Buckeye, Jonathan Rothschild of Tucson (pictured below), and Tom Schoaf of Litchfield Park.

2015-09-01 rothschild tucson gparents photo

Kinship care is not new, but it is growing. According to the U. S. Census Bureau, nearly 177,000 (5%) of Arizona’s children are being raised by family other than their parents, 67,000 of them by grandparents. Staying with family rather than in foster care is a good alternative for children because they need the stability of being in a familiar setting at a time when their lives are being disrupted.

Many grandparents with young children in their care may struggle to help raise them, both financially and physically. Grandfamilies need our support to help them get access to financial assistance, apply for health coverage for their grandchildren and establish a smoother process for gaining guardianship of the children in their care. Grandfamilies need to be able to easily find local training and support services for their grandchildren in their own neighborhoods.

Learn more about grandfamilies and kinship care here. If you are a grandparent raising your grandchildren, get peer support by joining the Arizona Grandparent Ambassadors at

Cities that proclaimed Kinship Care Month include: Apache Junction, Buckeye, Casa Grande, Florence, Gilbert, Goodyear, Humboldt, Litchfield Park, Payson, Phoenix, Prescott, Queen Creek, Safford, Scottsdale, Surprise, and Tucson.

Budget Requests Part 2: DJC and DHS

State agencies have submitted their funding requests for the next fiscal year which begins July 1. Over the next few weeks, CAA will continue to provide you with a snapshot of requests submitted by many of these agencies. Here, in our second installment, is a snapshot of the Arizona Department of Juvenile Corrections and the Department of Health Services (DHS).

Most of the DHS budget request concerns the creation of integrated services programs for two Medicaid populations in the behavioral health system –  individuals with serious mental illness and individuals who receive general mental health and substance abuse services.  Since these integrated programs require moving responsibilities and funding between the Department of Health Services and AHCCCS, we will report on all Medicaid programs in a separate e-news .

New Legislative District Fact Sheets

With KIDS COUNT® funding from the Annie E. Casey Foundation, Children’s Action Alliance is able to provide high-quality data and trend analysis to enrich local discussions about securing better futures for all children — and to raise the visibility of children’s issues through a nonpartisan, evidence-based lens.

2014 ld fact sheetOne popular data tool is the CAA Legislative District Fact Sheet so you can see how children in your district are doing. CAA recently updated the Legislative District Fact Sheets with the latest data, including important indicators such as Children Living in Poverty, Children without Health Insurance, Children in Household Receiving a Public Benefit and others.

We encourage you to use this local data when you meet with local elected officials and candidates. Find out how your candidates, state and U.S. senators and representatives plan to address the problems facing children in your community, and across the state.

As an added bonus, this year we have all the data for each legislative district in one spreadsheet available for download, so you can sort it and analyze it yourself. This extra bit of information can help you better understand where your legislative district ranks among all the others in each of the indicators on the fact sheet.

If you have any questions regarding the legislative district fact sheets or the candidate questionnaires, please contact Joshua Oehler at or at 602-266-0707 x204.